Criminal Law

Michigan must extend right of child sex assault survivors to sue

In recent years, Michigan has become a poster child for shocking examples of large-scale sexual abuse of children and young adults, as the horrific crimes of Larry Nassar at Michigan State University and Robert Anderson at the University of Michigan have come to light. Countless other survivors, whose abusers are not public figures, have gone unrecognized in the media.

While the Michigan Legislature made a temporary exception for Nassar’s victims, the state’s current statute of limitations for survivors of childhood sexual assault is frustratingly narrow. Survivors can only file civil lawsuits until they are 28 years old — one of the most restrictive policies in the country. That means that too many survivors are denied access to justice and the opportunity to hold their abusers accountable. 

As an attorney who has dealt with many cases of childhood sexual assault — and as a long-time board member of The Firecracker Foundation in Lansing, which provides holistic healing services for children who have experienced sexual trauma — I’ve seen firsthand how this restriction prevents valid claims from going forward. 

Many victims of sexual assault can take years to process their abuse. In fact, the average victim of child sex abuse is 52 years of age by the time they report what happened to them, according to Child USA, a national nonprofit that fights to prevent child abuse and neglect. Tragically, the Department of Justice estimates that 86 percent of child sexual abuse goes unreported, due to trauma, power dynamics and institutions that protect abusers. 

Thankfully, the Michigan Legislature is finally on the cusp of taking consequential action. A new set of bills, introduced by State Rep. Julie Brixie of Meridian Township in 2023, would have extended the civil statute of limitations, allowing victims of childhood sexual abuse to file claims until they are 52 years old. The bill also included a two-year amnesty period, effective after the law is enacted, that would have allow anyone to file lawsuits against their abusers, no matter how long ago the abuse took place.

Similar bills have been introduced in past sessions of the state legislature, only to languish due to fierce opposition from the very institutions that protected and enabled abusers, such as universities, churches and other organizations concerned with their financial liability, according to reporting from the Associated Press. Unfortunately, the bills did not make it through the legislative process in 2023.

That’s shameful. We can’t let it happen again. 

Childhood sexual abuse has a deep and long-lasting effect on survivors. Survivors are frequently diagnosed with depression, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder. Many have difficulty forming healthy romantic relationships. Self-harm and suicide attempts can result. The economic impact of this type of abuse can be devastating as survivors find themselves unable to maintain steady employment. Our state has a responsibility and an obligation to give survivors the tools they need to heal and to provide an avenue for authentic and meaningful justice. 

For too long, Michigan has failed survivors of child sexual abuse. These bills are expected to be reintroduced in the 2024 legislative session.  They represent a huge first step toward bringing Michigan in line with numerous other states that protect the rights of abuse survivors. It’s the least we can do for those who have had so much taken from them. 

Liz Abdnour is a partner at Abdnour Weiker, LLP

www.Lawyers4Students.com

HELP! I need to call a lawyer.

5 Things You Need to Know Before Contacting an Attorney 

  1. Understand Your Deadlines & Call as Soon as You Have Them 

    If you only need to respond with your intent to appeal, do so as soon as possible to start the process. For K12 items, this can generally be done via email to your child's school principal's office. You can have an attorney do this for you should you consult and retain them within the deadline to submit your intent to appeal. 

    If you have a hearing scheduled or need to submit an appeal, contact a lawyer several days in advance of this deadline, if not at least a whole week prior. 

    If you have an interview or investigation meeting, follow the same advice as if this was a hearing or appeal submission and contact a lawyer ASAP. 

  2. Documentation – Keep it Handy, But Share What is Requested 

    It is always helpful to keep all communications with your employer, school, university, an adverse party, etc., safe and secure. Attorneys will often request specific documents, i.e., IEPs, suspension notices, and ODE letters, so do have those ready to send. 

    As far as other communication goes, you can send these items to the firm you are contacting after scheduling a consult, though keep in mind that attorneys often will not have time to read each article in its entirety. 

  3. Have a General Understanding of Your Goals for Contacting an Attorney 

    In many cases, your objective to remedy your situation is clear, getting your child re-enrolled in school, appealing a court decision, getting assistance through a hearing, etc. However, you may feel a more general sense that an injustice has occurred, and you would like to see action taken. In either situation, it is best to gather a sense of your goals as a client to effectively communicate to an attorney’s office what type of assistance you need. Even a brief list of goals will be enough to have a successful initial consultation. 

  4. The First Person You Talk to at Their Office is Likely Not an Attorney (and They Did Not Do the Bad Thing to You) 

    This person, often an office administrator or intake coordinator, is here to answer questions about the firm you are contacting and create your file as a client. They will typically need to walk through a list of questions for their intake process and will likely have information to share with you about what that process entails.  

    Please keep in mind that they are the liaison between you and the attorney. They cannot control your case's outcome, answer any legal questions, or provide a remedy for the situation outside of getting you in touch with an attorney. 


  5. Retainers, Flat Fees, Contingency Defined 

    While many attorneys operate on a retainer fee structure, the most well-known payment structure is often referred to on billboards and commercials as "you don't pay unless we win." To distinguish the former from the latter, here are some general definitions of typical payment structures that lawyers utilize: 

    Retainers - A fee that the client pays upfront to an attorney to commence representation, which is held in trust until the attorney works on/earns the fee. With each piece of work that the attorney does, that balance will deplete. 

    Flat Fees – A fee paid upfront to cover all work that the attorney will perform. This is a fixed amount and is generally non-refundable. 

    Contingency – The lawyer or firm only receives compensation if they successfully represent the client. Commonly known as "pay if we win." 

* Please Note: The Concept of "Wins" *

Many people seeking an attorney will want to know, "what is your firm's 'win-rate' or 'record?'" Frankly, that metric is not typically logged or measured as it is difficult to assess what a "win" is, given how different each client's goals usually are. Thus, keep in mind that many offices will not have a straightforward response for this as there is not a straightforward answer in many cases. 

Own a dog? Fostering a dog? You NEED to read this!

Thank you to our first guest blogger, friend of the firm and Senior Assistant City Attorney  for the City of Columbus, Isaac Rinsky.

Mr. Rinsky is assigned to the Franklin County Environmental Court and has some great, easy to read info and tips for dog owners.

Imagine venturing out for a walk with your big snow boots and hat with your excited and cooped up dog.  All of a sudden, you see another adventurer walking towards you with their faithful canine companion.  As they approach, you realize that their dog is much bigger than yours.  You also realize that their dog is not on a leash. Several thoughts enter your head. Shouldn’t their dog be on a leash? What if their dog runs towards me and my dog?  What if their dog attacks me and my dog?

These are thoughts that undoubtedly all dog owners/walkers have pondered.

Before we address those questions, should we not first consider:  Who is responsible for the dog?

Many a distempered citizen has appeared in the Franklin County Environmental Court, just waiting for their chance to exclaim, “I am not the owner of that dog!”  What they fail to realize, and what is consolingly whispered to them, is that the Ohio Revised Code holds owners, keepers, or harborers of dogs responsible for many dog related offenses.  Some common examples of harboring or keeping a dog include: (1) Walking the dog, (2) Dog sitting, (3) Living in the same house with the dog, (4) Picking up the dog at the pound.  These are just a few common examples.  So before you agree to take care of a dog for a friend or pick it up at the pound, make sure to confirm that the dog is licensed and vaccinated.  If that dog gets loose while it is within your control, you may be held responsible.

Do you have to have your dog on a leash in Columbus? 

If you are on your own property, you must keep your dog confined to that property.

If your dog is a female and is in heat, then you must keep the dog on a leash if you leave your property. Otherwise, no leash required.

However, if you decide not to restrain your fur baby, here are some things to consider.  You or some other person must maintain reasonable control over your dog at all times.  So, if you are walking your dog without a leash, you better make sure he/she is well trained and will respond to verbal commands.

What if a dog attacks me or my dog?

If a dog is attacking you, you may have the right to injure or kill that dog.  If a dog is attacking your dog, you most likely cannot kill that dog. See O.R.C. 955.28(A).

If you are bit by a dog, or a dog kills your dog, then the owner, keeper, or harborer of the offending dog can be criminally liable.  If, after an investigation by Franklin County Animal Control, it is determined that a dog caused physical harm to a person, or that it killed another dog, the owner, keeper, or harborer of the dog can be charged with a fourth degree misdemeanor. The offending dog can also be designated as dangerous.

If a dog is designated as dangerous, this designation can be appealed within ten days.  The court will then determine whether there is sufficient evidence to show that the dog, without provocation, either caused injury (other than serious injury or death) to a person, or killed another dog. “Without Provocation” means that the dog was not teased, tormented, or abused by a person, or that the dog was not coming to the aid or defense of a person who was not engaged in illegal or criminal activity and who was not using the dog as a means of carrying out such activity.

If poor Fluffy is designated as dangerous, it does not mean she will be put down.  She can still live to a ripe old age barking at the sky and stealing hot dogs off the table.  You will have to register her as dangerous, have her fixed, microchipped, and she will have to wear a special collar to identify her as “dangerous”.  You also will have to confine her in a more secure manner than before.  See O.R.C. 955.22(D).

If, heaven forbid, Fluffy causes serious physical harm to a person, then the court may order her to take a forever nap.  Euthanasia is not required in this scenario, but if it is not ordered, the person responsible will have to obtain liability insurance for Fluffy that equals or exceeds $100,000.

What if Buddy got loose despite my best efforts to keep him contained in my yard?

Unfortunately, many courts in Ohio have held that dog confinement offenses are strict liability. This includes jailable offenses for confinement of dogs.  If Buddy picked the lock on your gate, or jumped over an impossibly high fence while you were at work, you could still be on the hook for his delinquency.

Hopefully this information will assist you and your furry friend this season.  Make sure your dog is registered, vaccinated, and under your control or confined to your yard at all times.  If not, you might find yourself talking to a Deputy from Franklin County Animal Control.  And they may ask you, “Who let the dogs out?”

Questions? Call us! 614.745.2001

Applying for Grad School? What you need to disclose.

When applying to graduate programs, especially law school, many applications require that all applicants disclose any criminal or academic misconduct. But it can be tricky to know what you do and do not need to disclose.

One simple answer is to read any disclosure questions carefully. While the disclosure questions can be lengthy, it is very important to read the entire question for two reasons: (1) To make sure that you do not mistakenly withhold any information and (2) To know specifically what you do and do not need to disclose.

Not all schools are the same and it is very possible that some schools require different information that other schools. Failing to disclose required information can result in having to take extra application steps, not being accepted to the school, or having your acceptance revoked. Ensuring that you are disclosing all relevant information can help ensure an easier application process. Reading the disclosure question thoroughly will help guarantee that you disclosed all requested information.

Tips to answering application disclosure questions:

  1. Read the question thoroughly

  2. WHEN IN DOUBT, DISCLOSE

  3. Know your criminal and academic history

Honesty is the best policy when it comes to disclosures on applications. If you are in doubt about whether to disclose a piece of information or not, it is always better to be honest and disclose rather than trying to hide the information. You also have the option of contacting the school and asking if a piece of information needs to be disclosed or not. It is important to know the  status of any criminal or academic misconduct you may have because in some cases if the charge was dismissed or expunged, you may not be required to disclose the misconduct. It will be stated in the disclosure question whether dismissed or expunged misconduct must be disclosed or not.

While some schools may require you to disclose minor traffic infractions, such as speeding, it is unlikely that a simple speeding ticket or other minor traffic violation will negatively affect your admissions odds. However, failing to disclose may negatively affect your admissions chance!

In short, make sure to read the disclosure questions carefully to find out exactly what must be disclosed, and if you are still on the fence about whether to disclose or not, always disclose.

Questions? Call us! 614.745.2001

Article written by Avery Young, 2L at Capital University Law School and Law Clerk for Abdnour Weiker, LLP